Current:Home > ContactBaltimore Sues 26 Fossil Fuels Companies Over Climate Change -WealthX
Baltimore Sues 26 Fossil Fuels Companies Over Climate Change
View
Date:2025-04-14 20:16:34
Baltimore has brought billions of dollars of investment to its waterfront, transforming the Inner Harbor into a model of urban revitalization over the past half century. But rising seas are now putting that investment at risk, and the city wants to hold the fossil fuel industry responsible.
On Friday, the city sued 26 fossil fuel companies, seeking to hold them financially accountable for the threats posed by climate change. Baltimore Solicitor Andre M. Davis said that the companies knew for decades that the use of their products was warming the atmosphere and could have grave consequences, but that they failed to take steps to reduce that harm.
“Baltimore’s residents, workers and businesses shouldn’t have to pay for the damage knowingly caused by these companies,” he said at a news conference with Mayor Catherine Pugh.
Baltimore is seeking compensation for protecting the city from the impacts of climate change, as well as punitive damages and an order that the companies relinquish some of their profits for allegedly misleading the public and policymakers about the harms posed by their products. It asks that the amount of damages be determined in a trial.
What’s Different from NYC’s Dismissed Case?
Baltimore is the latest in a growing list of more than a dozen cities, counties and states that have sued fossil fuel companies over climate change in the past year. Its lawsuit also comes less than 24 hours after a federal judge dismissed a similar case in New York City.
Davis said a key difference is that, unlike New York’s case, Baltimore’s is in state court.
The three city cases that have been thrown out—in New York City, San Francisco and Oakland—were all rejected by federal judges who agreed with the fossil fuel industry’s argument that federal laws, primarily the Clean Air Act, take precedence over state laws, and that Congress and the president are responsible for taking action, rather than the courts.
“Despite the federal court’s unfounded fear that legal solutions will prevent political ones, the justice system is not powerless to give relief to local communities that are harmed by global warming and rising sea levels,” Davis told InsideClimate News. He noted that in the 1950s, it was state judges in Delaware who ruled against discrimination in public school education, going against the federal tide at the time.
Legal scholars have suggested that the plaintiffs against the fossil fuel industry could have a better chance in state courts, and the industry has been working to get several of the cases moved to federal jurisdictions.
Fossil Companies Knew of the Risks
In its lawsuit, Baltimore alleges that fossil fuel companies knew for nearly 50 years that the production and use of fossil fuels created greenhouse gases responsible for global warming. Yet at the same time, it says, the companies engaged in a coordinated effort to hide that understanding and undertake a campaign to discredit the growing body of science confirming the connection.
It claims that the 26 companies named are responsible for about 15 percent of the carbon dioxide emissions between 1965 and 2015. The consequences of that increase in atmospheric CO2 include extreme weather events and sea level rise, both particular threats to Baltimore, the lawsuit says.
“As a direct and proximate consequence of defendants’ wrongful conduct … flooding and storms will become more frequent and more severe, and average sea level will rise substantially along Maryland’s coast, including in Baltimore,” says the 130-page lawsuit, filed in the Circuit Court for Baltimore City.
The city cites a 2014 study by Climate Central that projected that within 80 years, Baltimore could see annual flooding that would break today’s records. The same study found that sea level rise driven by climate change has already increased the likelihood of extreme floods in and around Baltimore by at least 20 percent.
Baltimore is already facing winters and springs with more extreme precipitation and summers that are longer, hotter and drier, according to the lawsuit. Two months ago, the region was hit with a 1,000-year storm that brought torrential rains and flash floods.
It also faces the burden of addressing public health impacts associated with climate change, including heat-related illnesses and worsening allergies, the lawsuit says.
The Inner Harbor and Infrastructure at Risk
Baltimore’s waterfront is particularly vulnerable to the impacts of sea level rise because of its dense development and low-lying areas, the lawsuit says.
The port and waterfront provide jobs and a strong property tax base for the city. The revitalized Inner Harbor attracts more than 20 million visitors a year to an aquarium, museums, historic ships, restaurants and hotels.
Beyond the waterfront, the city’s roads, rail lines, emergency response facilities, wastewater facilities and power plants are all vulnerable to extreme weather, the lawsuit says.
Like the other cities, including tiny Imperial Beach, California, that are waging legal war with the fossil fuel industry, Baltimore says it cannot afford the cost of mitigating climate change impacts.
veryGood! (2)
Related
- At site of suspected mass killings, Syrians recall horrors, hope for answers
- 4 Indian soldiers killed and 3 wounded in an ambush by rebels in disputed Kashmir
- Rudy Giuliani files for bankruptcy days after being ordered to pay $148 million in defamation case
- Hungary’s Orbán says he agreed to a future meeting with Ukrainian President Zelenskyy
- Whoopi Goldberg is delightfully vile as Miss Hannigan in ‘Annie’ stage return
- U.S. helps negotiate cease-fire for Congo election as world powers vie for access to its vital cobalt
- Maryland prison contraband scheme ends with 15 guilty pleas
- Taliban official says Afghan girls of all ages permitted to study in religious schools
- Woman dies after Singapore family of 3 gets into accident in Taiwan
- It's the winter solstice. Here are 5 ways people celebrate the return of light
Ranking
- The 401(k) millionaires club keeps growing. We'll tell you how to join.
- After approving blessings for same-sex couples, Pope asks Vatican staff to avoid ‘rigid ideologies’
- UEFA, FIFA 'unlawful' in European Super League blockade. What this means for new league
- Morgan Wallen makes a surprise cameo in Drake's new music video for 'You Broke My Heart'
- Toyota to invest $922 million to build a new paint facility at its Kentucky complex
- Man who killed 83-year-old woman as a teen gets new shorter sentence
- UN says more than 1 in 4 people in Gaza are ‘starving’ because of war
- Man accused of texting death threats to Ramaswamy faces similar charges involving 2 more candidates
Recommendation
Highlights from Trump’s interview with Time magazine
Stop Right Now and Get Mel B's Update on Another Spice Girls Reunion
Toyota recalls 1 million Toyota and Lexus vehicles because air bag may not deploy properly
Actor Jonathan Majors found guilty on 2 charges in domestic assault trial
Finally, good retirement news! Southwest pilots' plan is a bright spot, experts say
Wisconsin Republican proposal to legalize medical marijuana coming in January
Dollar General robbery suspect shot by manager, crashes into bus, dies: Texas authorities
Oprah identifies this as 'the thing that really matters' and it's not fame or fortune